Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer – no Kindle device required. Learn more
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle Cloud Reader.
Using your mobile phone camera, scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
Enter your mobile phone or email address
By pressing "Send link", you agree to Amazon's Conditions of Use.
You consent to receive an automated text message from or on behalf of Amazon about the Kindle App at your mobile number above. Consent is not a condition of any purchase. Message and data rates may apply.
Lincoln in the Bardo Audio CD
Enhance your purchase
Frequently bought together
- Language : English
- ISBN-10 : 1489410678
- ISBN-13 : 978-1489410672
- Item weight : 66 g
- Dimensions : 13.2 x 1.4 x 12.2 cm
- Customer Reviews:
Top reviews from Canada
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
I have been meaning to pick this book since November 2017 and I have the physical copy on my shelves since August 2019. I borrowed the audiobook around 16 times before actually reading this. All in all, to say that this was a book I was apprehensive about would be an understatement. I was expecting this mediation on loss and grief which would only help making me depressed too - what I got was something that did talk about grief but also about grace, moving on and life’s absolute absurdity and our delusions - both internal and external.
The first thing that struck me was how funny this was - some parts are comedic and entertaining (especially the main three narrators in the Bardo) but even the constant historical excerpts about the Lincolns made me grin. In the space of a page, the President was accused of being a bad father, a good father, indifferent and grief stricken. We never got to hear from him directly - there was always a distance between us and the reader - either through the ghosts or the “historical” texts. That struck me as I felt that the author was pointing out the futility of ever knowing someone - especially in terms of knowing someone’s history and the fallacy of making conclusions of intent. (Not all the excerpts are from the real books which makes one question what is actually ‘read’ and ‘false’. It kept me on my toes and sent me down a google rabbit hole periodically - so cool).
The audiobook was fantastic - fully narrated which added an immediacy to some of the longer passages. I did also follow along the narration with a book which was the right mix for me. This novel works more like a play with the character’s direct dialogue but the ability to go back and re-read the print quickly or pause and focus on the ridiculous titles of the “historical” texts was interesting.
There are passages which the spelling is archaic or not correct (e.g:
“Begins, I’ll piss a line of toxic in yr wretched twin wristcuts Groping you by ye clubsick, Vollman, I’ll slag you into the black fence.” )
which reflects a state of mind of the ghost which the audio narrator doesn’t fully get across. However, the audio reflect class differences through accent and cadence so clearly that I honestly think this book should both be read and listened to simultaneously.
You can also see Mr Saunders’ short story background play out here. A lot of the ghosts' dialogue worked like little vignettes, some were poignantly funny and some were sad. And some fluctuated back and forth.
In the end, I loved the surrealness of the book - I was reminded of Lost Gods which was also set in purgatory. And despite the fact that the latter book had more violence and literal gods / monsters, this was more atmospheric and weird. This book didn’t really explain what was happening but just asked you as a reader to gamely follow along.
I loved this book - I had 9 pages of thoughts on this! Definitely worth getting the audiobook and giving this a try. I agree with the Guardian which called this book “a performance of great formal daring. It perhaps won’t be to everyone’s taste, but minor missteps aside it stands head and shoulders above most contemporary fiction .
Just don't wait for 3 year before picking this up.
Combining the historical research with the process and product of their fertile imaginations, they then melded stories into novels with unorthodox narrative structures. They are by far not the first to develop structures for their novels that deviate from the traditional linear and chronological format. Sometimes such experimentation works brilliantly, sometimes not so well.
In any novel, it takes a while for us readers to figure out what’s happening, who the characters are, and how they are interacting. Unorthodox structures can make a novel a particularly challenging read especially in the initial stages. In “All the Light We Cannot See,” Doerr flips back and forth in time and runs multiple storylines in parallel. In “Lincoln in the Bardo,” Saunders intersperses direct historical quotations with the dialogue of characters and he places the whole novel’s text in stand-alone statements explicitly attributed to specific characters, historic or imagined.
The provocative structure of “Lincoln in the Bardo” has defeated more than one reader that I know who have given up on the book, finding it just too confusing … and that’s quite apart from the fantastical depiction of purgatory-dwelling spirits interacting with living human beings in the cemetery where Abraham Lincoln comes to mourn the death of his eleven-year-old son Willie.
The lives from childhood to early adulthood of Marie-Laure and Werner are told in alternating chapters in “All the Light We Cannot See” and it takes a while to figure that out. The challenges for the reader are compounded by many of the fourteen sections of the book each made up of multiple chapters being arranged in non-chronological order: 1944, 1934, 1944, 1940, 1944, 1941, 1944, 1942, 1944, 1944, 1944, 1945, 1974, 2014.
So, Doerr and Saunders are challenging our imagination as readers not only to engage with the characters that they have created but also to do so through complex organizational structures.
Are they successful in challenging us yet keeping us reading until the end?
The more unorthodox of the two was the one to which I responded more enthusiastically. I was totally perplexed initially when I started “Lincoln in the Bardo” but I was hooked once I figured out what was going on and how the structure and even the page layout contributed to the evolution of the story. Saunders has crafted a story of immense metaphorical complexity and heart-rending poignancy. I loved it.
I appreciate the beauty of the writing in “All the Light We Cannot See” and the tough yet tender WWII story that Doerr tells. The structure was somewhat problematic for me at the start but I got over that difficulty relatively easily. What I didn’t get was being grabbed in the heart and the intellect. My imagination was provoked but coasted relatively dormant through 530 pages.
I’m glad that I’ve read both of them but it is Saunders’ “Lincoln in the Bardo” that I’m raving about to friends.
Top reviews from other countries
To address one other point made about this book in reviews, it is not a difficult or challenging read. It takes a little bit of time at the start to tune in to it, but once you understand how the author is telling his tale, it is a very easy and enjoyable read.
This is the story of the death of Abraham Lincoln's young son Willie. It is told by two different sets of voices. Firstly, the actually events around Willie's death are told in a series of snippets from contemporary observers. In telling his story in this way, author George Saunders comments on the unreliability of history, and on the changing perceptions of great historical figures. The Lincoln of this book is at the start if the Civil War and deeply unpopular in some quarters. To some observers his relationship with his son is deeply moving, to others he is a cold and callous father.
The second set of voices is what sets this book apart. They are spirits, ghosts, the undead, remaining on earth in some form of limbo (in some schools of Buddhism, Bardo is a transitional state between death and rebirth) invisible to the living. Chief among these spirits are a churchman, a printer who died before he could consummate his marriage to his younger wife, and a gay man who committed suicide.
The spirits, seemingly unaware that they are dead, referring to their coffins as sick boxes, seek to protect Willie from a form of death, referred to by the citizens of the realm as "matterlightblooming" and from the more malicious inhabitants of their netherworld. They also hope to re-establish a connection between Willie and his father in the hope that he can return to the normal world as a precursor to their also doing so.
In portraying Lincoln's grief at the death of his son, the book is deeply moving, but given that it's primary subject is death, it is surprisingly light, and often genuinely humorous. Alongside Lincoln's grief, Saunders depicts the doubts which wrack him as a leader taking his country into war. He is forced to understand his own grief at a time when his decisions will inevitably lead to other deaths and other parents being similarly bereaved.
The other great theme is, unsurprisingly for the period, that of slavery and relationships between European and African Americans. Oppression and conflict continue into the twilight world, although the ultimate suggestion of where Lincoln obtained his final resolve to fight the war to its end is astonishing.
Also in the graveyard are many other spirits who live in the Bardo which is considered in some schools of Buddhism to be an intermediate state between death and rebirth. The 3 main voices are the spirits are a reverend, a printer who died before he could consummate his marriage to his younger wife, and a gay man who committed suicide, and the book is written almost like a script. As well as the narrative from the voices, the book is interspersed with historical writings of the time, describing the events as they unfolded (I'm not clear if these are true quotations as there is no bibliography but I assume they are!) Other themes include racism (even after death the coloured people don't interact with the white people) and slavery
I really enjoyed the book - it took a few pages to get used to the format but I found it a quick read and as with many other historical based novels I have read, it has made me want to read more about Lincoln At times I found some of the interaction between the 3 main voices quite amusing and this innovative style of writing will stay with me I think.