In this major, paradigm-shifting work, Kojin Karatani systematically re-evaluates Marx's version of world history, shifting the focus of critique from modes of production to modes of exchange.

Karatani seeks to understand both capital-nation-state, the interlocking system that's the dominant form of modern global society, and the possibilities for superseding it. He traces different modes of exchange, including the pooling of resources that characterizes nomadic tribes, the gift exchange systems developed after the adoption of fixed-settlement agriculture, the exchange of obedience for protection that arises with the emergence of the state, the commodity exchanges that characterize capitalism, and, finally, a future mode of exchange based on the return of gift exchange, albeit modified for the contemporary moment. He argues that this final stage - marking the overcoming of capital, nation, and state - is best understood in light of Kant's writings on eternal peace. The Structure of World History is in many ways the capstone of Karatani's brilliant career, yet it also signals new directions in his thought.

The book was published by Duke University Press.

Listening Length

15 hours and 18 minutes
Author

Kojin Karatani
Narrator

Bob Dunsworth
Audible release date

Oct. 14 2015
Language

English
Publisher

University Press Audiobooks
ASIN

B0725MGKFS
Version

Unabridged
Program Type

Audiobook
See all details

Your complimentary audiobook is waiting

Free trial includes 1 credit in your first month good for any title of your choice, yours to keep.
Plus, you can enjoy unlimited listening to The Plus Catalogue—thousands of Audible Originals, podcasts, and audiobooks.
You'll unlock exclusive member-only sales, as well as 30% off your purchases of any additional titles.
After 30 days Audible is $14.95/month + applicable taxes. Renews automatically.

Learn more about membership

Sold and delivered by Audible, an Amazon company

List Price: $33.01

You Save: $4.13 (13%)

By completing your purchase, you agree to Audible's Conditions Of Use and Amazon's Privacy Notice. Tax where applicable.

Sold and delivered by Audible, an Amazon company

Related to this topic

Page 1 of 1Start OverPage 1 of 1

Product details

Listening Length	15 hours and 18 minutes
Author	Kojin Karatani
Narrator	Bob Dunsworth
Audible.ca Release Date	October 14 2015
Publisher	University Press Audiobooks
Program Type	Audiobook
Version	Unabridged
Language	English
ASIN	B0725MGKFS
Best Sellers Rank	#10,995 in Audible Books & Originals (See Top 100 in Audible Books & Originals) #48 in International Economic Conditions (Books) #70 in Financial Economic Conditions #71 in Economic Conditions (Books)

Customer reviews

4.4 out of 5

30 global ratings

5 star		68%
4 star		17%
3 star		10%
2 star 0% (0%)		0%
1 star		4%

How are ratings calculated?

Top review from Canada

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

wanqing

Five Stars

Reviewed in Canada 🇨🇦 on February 27, 2015

Verified Purchase

Great book! Useful for tests in University of Toronto lol. Fast delivery.

Helpful

Top reviews from other countries

Ken Woods

A fresh and radical perspective

Reviewed in the United Kingdom 🇬🇧 on January 5, 2023

Verified Purchase

I particularly liked the reinforcement of his arguments through selective repetition which made the build up of his arguments easier to follow. Nonetheless I will probably need to read the book again!

yojiseki

アジールについての補足

Reviewed in Japan 🇯🇵 on May 11, 2014

Verified Purchase

どこかで柄谷が予告していた通り、『世界史の構造』英語版p.130には日本語版第二部第四章1「呪術から
宗教へ」193頁に対応する部分にオルトヴィン・ヘンスラーの主張したアジールについての学説がアニマに関
連して半頁ほど追加されている。その他、英語版序文や索引が新たについた。

　　There are, however, instances of magic filling an egalitarian function
even in state societies : we see this in instances of the right of asylum. Under
it, people are freed from social constraints. The right of asylum is universal
to state societies. It possesses an ethical significance that liberates people
from social constraints and limits. This does not spring up from humanism.
Ortwin Henssler argues that the right of asylum originated in magic, not
in some ethical significance.(5) But how could something magical in nature
acquire ethical significance? In my view, the right to asylum represents the
return of suppressed mode of exchange A (that of nomadic egalitarianism)
during the period when clan society transformed into state society. In
that sense, the right to asylum harbored an ethical significance from the
start. But it was manifested in the form of a compulsion, the return of the
repressedーas, in other words，a kind of magical power. State power is not
able to touch people who claim asylum because they possess a kind of anima.

なお、アジールに関する部分以外に、ギリシアに関する部分も全面的に改稿、追記されている。
アーレントの引用など、全体の主題と重なるし、『哲学の起源』の要約的な箇所もある。
個人的には緩やかな連合体の象徴としてオリンピアの競技会を挙げたのが印象的だった。
文庫版( 世界史の構造 (岩波現代文庫) )はこちらの英語版に対応している。

10 people found this helpful

Etienne RP

Between Marx and Anthropology

Reviewed in the United States 🇺🇸 on June 3, 2014

Verified Purchase

There is a tradition of contemporary Japanese philosophers drawing from anthropology (the names of Shinichi Nakazawa and Akira Asada come to mind). There is also a Japanese tradition of philosophical re-readings of Marx (with Kozo Uno or Makoto Itoh). I am interested in the first tradition. I regard the second as negligible. In The Structure of World History, Kojin Karatani combines the two approaches. He offers a broad synthesis on the origins of the state, the market, and the national community, based on the works of classical anthropologists. And he provides a close reading of Marx's texts in order to construct his own philosophical system, encompassing the whole of human history. I found the first part based on anthropology most valuable. I only skipped through the second part. Below are a few reading notes and commentary intended to provided a cursory reading of Karatani's book.

Marx, like Comte and Hegel before him, saw the history of the human race as neatly divided into historical phases. He identified five such phases: the primitive horde, Asiatic despotism, the ancient classic state, Germanic feudalism, and the modern state under capitalism. The principle of that division was to be found in modes of production and the type of labor relations they generated. The stateless clan society was characterized by primitive communism: there was no private property, and goods were shared among all members of the clan. It was followed by the Asiatic mode of production in which the despotic king owned everything and his subjects nothing. Then came the Greek and Roman slavery system giving power to a minority of citizens, followed by the Germanic feudal system with its relations of allegiance and serfdom, and modern bourgeois capitalism characterized by the opposition between capital and labor. Thus Marx famously proclaimed that all history was the history of class struggle, and that it necessarily tended towards the advent of communism, in which class would disappear and the state would wither away.

Other authors, mainly inspired by Marx, offered their own classification of social formations. To the five modes of production identified by Marx, Samir Amin added two others: the trade-based social system seen in various Arab countries, and the social formation based on the "simple petty-commodity" mode of production seen in seventeenth-century Britain. Building his own theory of world systems, Immanuel Wallerstein described a succession from mini-systems that preceded the rise of the state, to world empires that were ruled by a single state, and then world-economies in which multiple states engaged in competition without being unified politically. The modern world system of global capitalism itself went through the successive stages of mercantilism, liberalism, and imperialism, each dominated by a single hegemonic power: first Holland, then Britain, and then the United States.

Yet other thinkers identified various stages of development by the dominant world commodity or technology: the wool industry in the stage of mercantilism, the textile industry in liberalism, heavy industries in imperialism, and durable consumer goods such as automobiles and electronics in the stage of capitalism. Our present times may witness the rise of a new stage in which information serves as the world commodity. Still for others, each historical phase is characterized by the dominant mode of energy supply: from biomass and wood to windmills and hydropower and then to coal and steam, then electricity and the oil engine, followed by gas turbines and nuclear power or renewable energies. These periodicizations are only variants of a dominant scheme that locates the crux of world history in the realm of production.

While offering his own teleology based on modes of exchange as opposed to modes of production, Karatani introduces variants and correctives in these classifications in order to paint a more complex picture of world history. For instance, he argues that societies existed in the form of nomadic bands before the rise of clan society, and that the real turning point came with the adoption of fixed settlements, with its accompanying institutions of property, religious rituals, and political coercion. Contrary to the standard view of the Neolithic revolution that associates sedentarization with agriculture, he argues that fixed settlements preceded the appearance of agriculture, and first took the form of fishing villages located at the mouth of rivers and trade routes. Stockpiling was first made possible through the technology for smoking fish, not piling grain or herding livestock. Nomadic tribes on one side, and clan societies on the other, engaged in different modes of exchange and redistribution: pooling of resources and "primitive communism" for the first, and the logic of the gift and the forms of trade described by classical anthropologists for the second. Along with Pierre Clastres and Marshall Sahlins, he agrees that primitive societies were "societies against the state", and actively resisted the concentration of power through warfare and reciprocity of exchange.

Karatani also develops a more nuanced picture of the Asiatic state, considered by Hegel and Marx as well as by Karl Wittfogel as the symbol of despotism. Contrary to the vision of tyranny and oppression, he argues that the Asiatic social contract was based on a form of redistribution. People were not simply coerced: they voluntarily undertook to work for the sake of their king-priest, driven by religious beliefs and the offer for protection. State power is based on a specific mode of exchange, distinct from the first mode based on the reciprocity of the gift. Drawing resources from large-scale irrigation systems, the Asiatic state developed the first bureaucracies, created the first permanent standing armies, and organized long-distant trade with other communities. Through his bureaucrats, the despot was expected to rule, administer, show concern for, and take care of its subjects. It was not the Asiatic community that gave birth to the Asiatic despotic state; to the contrary, it was only after the establishment of a centralized state that a new community would emerge.

Karatani also offers a revision of our understanding of Greek and Roman antiquity. As he demonstrates, political theories and philosophy did not first emerge in the Greek polis, as is sometimes alleged. The formation of Asiatic states was associated with intense philosophical debates, as in the Warring States period in China which saw the emergence of the Hundred Schools of Thought. This is because the appearance of the state required a breaking with the traditions that had existed since clan society. Greece and Rome existed at the periphery of Asian empires and retained many aspects of clan societies. Rome in the end did become a vast empire, but that was due if anything to its adoption of the Asiatic imperial system, which survived the fall of Rome with the Byzantine dynasty and then the Islamic empires. For this reason, historians should regard the despotic state that emerged in Asia not simply as a primitive early stage, but rather as the entity that perfected the supranational state (or empire). Likewise, they should regard Athens and Rome not as the wellspring of Western civilization, but as incomplete social formations that developed at the submargins of Asian empires. Drawing from Karl Wittfogel, Karatani sees a subtle dialectics between civilizations-empires at the core, vassal states at the margins, independent polities at the submargin, and out-of-sphere communities that retained their nomadic lifestyle.

Moving to his third mode of exchange, based on money and commodities, Karatani enters classic Marxian terrain, and offers vintage Marx analysis. That is where he kind of lost me, and my reading of this part is wholly incomplete. Drawing from the classic formulas M-C-M' and M-M', he argues that the world created by this third mode of exchange is fundamentally a world of credit and speculation, and that it still needs the backing of the first mode (based on reciprocity) and the second mode (drawing from the social contract offered by the state) in order to sustain itself. My attention also lapsed during his discussions on world money, world commodities, and world systems à la Wallerstein. It was only revived when he described the different schools of socialist thinking, seeing great commonality between Proudhon and Marx as well as with the Young Hegelians who first developed a theory of alienation of the individual through a critique of religion, state power, and capital.

Karatani then introduces his fourth mode of exchange, labelled mode D, which marks the attempt to restore the reciprocal community of mode A on top of the market economy of mode C, and without the state structure of mode B. Although this mode of exchange is an ideal form that never existed in actuality, it manifested itself in the form of universal religions and expressed the "return of the repressed" of the primitive community's mode of reciprocal exchange in a higher dimension. His analysis sometimes borders on the bizarre, as when he warns of a looming ecological catastrophe and generalized warfare that may take humanity back to the stage of the nomadic tribe. His description of Kant as a closet socialist advocating the disappearance of the state and of capital also seems far-fetched. But it is his reading of Marx and Hegel through Kant that may provide the greatest food for thought to modern philosophers such as Slavoj Zizek, who quotes Karatani eloquently in his books. Based on solid anthropological data and a re-reading of Marx's classic texts, Karatani's work may generate a thousand theoretical explosions, placing the construction of world history systems back at the heart of the philosophical agenda.

53 people found this helpful

Hubert Shea

A new conceptual tour de force to dymystify human history

Reviewed in the United States 🇺🇸 on August 16, 2014

Verified Purchase

This book covers a conceptual tour de force to dymystify vicissitudes of the history of social formations between the era of the nomadic hunters-gatherers and the twentieth-first century. Karatani utilizes four modes of exchanges, including reciprocity, plunder and redistribution, commodity exchange, and return of reciprocity in a higher dimension, to offer a more comprehensive and vivid explication of why and how the borromean knot of state, nation, and capital has impinged on the historical evolution of social formations.

In a nutshell, this book brings unique values to the study of human history with an amazing bit of certain prescience in the demonstration of the world system beyond capitalism. Unlike Francis Fukuyama’s “end of history” hypothesis, Karatani concludes that communism is not necessary an oxymoron since the last phrase of human history is a “return of the repressed” in which social formation will be tantamount to restoration of the reciprocal mode in the ancient world but in a higher dimension. Karatani neither adopts nor supports a lineal view on human history and he pithily synthesizes a vast amount of Marxist, Hegelian, and Kantian literature to reconstruct the salient features of world history which are both cyclical and oblique. He further argues that the modes of production as adopted by Marx to adumbrate human history have demonstrated huge deficiency lest nation and state, as part of the ideological superstructure, are not taken into account succinctly by Marx.

This book is impressive, comprehensive, and well-written with very unique and well-argued point of view. It advances our new understanding of the structure of world history as well as the likely trajectory of ongoing transformation – or not - of social formation in the twentieth-first century.

14 people found this helpful

jgrompone

Four Stars

Reviewed in the United States 🇺🇸 on March 13, 2015

Verified Purchase

An interesting point of view from a new-Marxist economist.

See all reviews

Amazon Music Stream millions of songs	Amazon Advertising Find, attract and engage customers	Amazon Business Everything for your business	Amazon Drive Cloud storage from Amazon	Amazon Web Services Scalable Cloud Computing Services

Book Depository Books With Free Delivery Worldwide	Goodreads Book reviews & recommendations	IMDb Movies, TV & Celebrities	Amazon Photos Unlimited Photo Storage Free With Prime	Shopbop Designer Fashion Brands

Warehouse Deals Open-Box Discounts	Whole Foods Market We Believe in Real Food	Amazon Renewed Like-new products you can trust	Blink Smart Security for Every Home

The Structure of World History: From Modes of Production to Modes of Exchange Audible Audiobook – Unabridged

Included with free trial $0.00$0.00

Buy with 1-Click $28.88$28.88

Related to this topic

Product details

Customer reviews

Top review from Canada

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

Top reviews from other countries

Included with free trial

$0.00

Buy with 1-Click

$28.88