To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzes reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Good, but not great. Enjoyed the theme of Edwards on the beauty of God. But, in some very important ways, Ortlund doesn't seem to be a very careful reader, and therefore, critic of Edwards at the points where he deserves (and sometimes doesn't deserve) to be critiqued.
For example, when critiquing Edwards' so-called over-emphasis on introspection, he compares the teenage Edwards in his Resolutions and other early reflections to the mature David Brainerd, twenty years later. If anything, he should have compared the more mature Edwards to the mature David Brainerd on the subject to be critiqued. (To say that Edwards' belief on this or that subject (e.g., introspection) is this or that, you have to say which Edwards--the younger Edwards or the older, more mature Edwards.)
In order to read, interpret, and critique Edwards rightly, fairly, and thoroughly, you have to do so along his chronology of life--and thus noticing how he has changed, matured, and developed (personally, spiritually, theologically, etc.). In other words, Edwards along with every other theologian, must be read, interpreted, and critiqued in context. This way of reading Edwards is largely missing from Ortlund's portrayal of Edwards on the Christian Life. This is really unfortunate.