Top critical review
Reviewed in Canada on October 31, 2017
The discs are defective, especially "The Desolation of Smaug" in 3D. They play occasionally, but never all 3 movies in row. I've tried them in 2 different LG players and a Panasonic. I really liked the movies, but it was really frustrating to try an watch a movie, only to find that it did not work (in some cases at all, in some cases I had to eject and retry multiple times and in other, use a different player).